The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch

In which we discuss ageism and life before witch-killing bullets.  Michelle hints at her platonic ideal of a Sam-save, still many seasons away.  SPOILERS for seasons 1-14.  We would love to hear fro…

We're back!  And we have a lot to say about this episode.  Topics of discussion include An American Tail, Tom Bombadil's role in the apocalypse, and a surprisingly positive take on season 13. SPOILE…

In which we discuss the brothers’ personal idols, the appropriate apportioning of blame, and the current status of Paris Hilton.  Also included: a friendly round of Spot the Canadian, and the introdu…

In which we discuss the continuity of zombies, Samifer’s Panamanian dictator suit, and the thesis of the entire series.  Also featured: your feedback on the highs and lows of season 4! SPOILERS for …

In which we discuss chemistry with Lucifer, SO MANY SHORT SLEEVES, passivity and exploitation, and the freakiest example of clothes-sharing we’ve found so far. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We would l…

In which we discuss Sam’s disappointing lack of soliloquies, the under-utilization of anti-possession tattoos, and doing the right thing for the wrong reasons. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We would l…

In which we discuss Kripke’s graphically poetic turns of phrase, Dad’s Monopoly scratchers, the show’s inverted deism, and OHMYGODBECKY. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We would love to hear from you!  …

In which we discuss our favorite Netflix summary of the entire series, Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, our personal saga of demon-sabotaged phone calls, and The Thing We Refuse To Speak Of. SPOILER…

In which we discuss the shades of Sam’s subconscious, drinking your way through detox, and Bobby as our real dad.  (It’s spring again, which means Michelle is teaching Hamlet, so get ready for some S…

In which we discuss actor differentiation and symbols for addiction, while trying to estimate how much therapy Claire is going to need. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We would love to hear from you!  Y…

In which we discuss the ethics of ghoul-hunting and underage drinking, the birth order breakdown of protecting vs. equipping the ones you love, our personal jump the shark moments, and the minefield …

In which we discuss the extremest of extreme ret-conning, the show’s relationship with its fans, prayer as an angelic walkie-talkie, and literary symmetry between seasons 2 and 4.  Chuck-saves are fi…

In which Sam Winchester’s friendly tech support advice saves our podcast. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We would love to hear from you!  You can email us at [email protected].  You can leave us a…

In which we discuss Scholasticism, prerequisites for drinking demon blood, another Sam Save for the tally, and the confusing continuity of angel blades.  Also: Bethany returns to her angel pet peeves…

In which we discuss exceptionality and the “natural order,” the Dean/Tessa ship that never sailed, “Happy Days,” and lies lies lies. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We would love to hear from you!  You …

In which we discuss ominous meal prep shots, the subversion of siren sexuality, and the circumstances under which it is permissible to hack your best friend’s phone. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We w…

In which fingerprint requirements continue to complicate the believability of our undercover escapades.  Special guest Rachel joins us to discuss high school movie tropes, the line between justice an…

In which we discuss Dean’s safe word, the timeline of Sam’s addiction, what hunters and rockers have in common, and Michelle’s childhood as the daughter of a magician. SPOILERS for Seasons 1-13. We…

In which we reverse our usual roles of Buzzkill and Enthusiast, and discuss machismo as a villain, the seesaw of moral high ground, and the unforgivable crime of killing a dog.  Also featured: additi…

In which we discuss angelic metaphysics, Dean’s philosophical approach to “eating and crapping,” the side effects of angel sex, the infamous torture bikini, and some big glaring PARALLELS. SPOILERS …