The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch

In which we discuss Supernatural Bingo, handkerchief first aid, and Sam’s alternate life in the OC. SPOILERS for seasons 1-12. We would love to hear from you!  You can email us at theplaidcast@gmai…

In which we discuss the desires of demons, the ingredients of a hurricane, and the Shakespearean aspects of black eye-flashing.  Also featured: your feedback on the highs and lows of Season 2! SPOIL…

In which we utterly fail at math.  Episode discussion includes the powerful draw of nostalgic objects, what makes a believable hunter community, Sam’s compulsive apologizing, and our mixed feelings a…

In which special guest Rachel returns to help us discuss Dean as mother, early 2000s feminism, and the symbolic function of ketchup.  SPOILERS for seasons 1-12. We would love to hear from you!  You…

Welcome to Season 3!  In this episode we discuss Sam’s total lack of boundaries, the seven deadly sins of the hunter community, and our foolproof guide to identifying Canadian actors. SPOILERS for s…

In which we discuss unexpected hugs, the harrowing of hell, and the nutritional label on 100% pure Sammy. SPOILERS for seasons 1-12. We would love to hear from you!  You can email us at theplaidcas…

In which we discuss the morality of super powers, Beauty and the Beast parallels, and a very literal approach to “you are what you eat.” SPOILERS for seasons 1-11. We would love to hear from you!  …

In which we discuss the earned use of photographs as a tool for building pathos, the Karamozovian way in which our wishes shape reality, and the wrongness of Sam’s hair. SPOILERS for seasons 1-11. …

In which we are joined by special guest Ryan to discuss the brothers’ Anglo-Saxon dedication to debt-repayment, the Pollockian quality of Green River County Detention Center, and the cinematic art of…

In which we discuss Michelle’s neverending snobbery, the flaws of realism, our hatred for Enochian, and the best places to make out at Disneyland. SPOILERS for seasons 1-11! We would love to hear f…

In which we discuss the metaphorical significance of werewolves, the heinous iniquity of those who fold their underwear, and our long-standing debate on whether lycanthropy is an instant death senten…

In which we ponder the personhood of ghosts, Dad’s “inspiring” words of wisdom, and the things that would compel us to return as vengeful spirits.  Also featured: Michelle defends the relevance of ca…

In which we discuss Shakespeare’s Puck as an analog to the Trickster, the Winchesters’ beer preferences, and high school Sam’s Floridian alligator adventure. SPOILERS for seasons 1-11! We would lov…

In which we discuss Meg trying too hard to dress like a Winchester, a turning point for Jo, and whether or not we could shoot our siblings. SPOILERS for seasons 1-11! We would love to hear from you…

In which we discuss Sam’s logical faith and Dean’s experiential skepticism, the lacuna of Sam’s prayer life, and the Impala as Dean’s Holy of Holies. SPOILERS for seasons 1-11! We would love to hea…

In which we discuss Take Charge Sam, the culpability and responsibility of civilians, and our favorite music cues of the series.  Visit our Facebook page to listen to music cues we love and share you…

In which Michelle elaborates on what makes a "hearty, well-balanced Supernatural episode," we explore the menacing connotations of playground spinny things, and Bethany bids farewell to Sam's cast.  …

In which we discuss Dean’s secret love for Little House on the Prairie, come up with our own duress code, and revisit the critical debate of how to define a Sam-save.

In which we discuss the convergence of the show’s themes, the Winchesters as a superior Romeo and Juliet, and the questionable chemistry of sulfuric blood.

In which we experience lots of technical difficulties. :(  (So sorry!)  Discussion includes Faustian tales, ambition vs. desperation, and why Michelle loves goofer dust.