The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch

Thank you for all of your thoughtful questions!  Today we take a stab at answering them. We would love to hear from you! Email: [email protected] Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/theplaidcast

In which we discuss our Best and Worst of season 9, a close reading of "I lied" and "I'm proud of us," and one of the most shocking twists in the series. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlie…

In which we discuss ancient emails, missing dialogue, Gadreel's redemption, and the writers' comparisons to an HBO series that we did not expect. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episod…

No one in the history of torture has ever been tortured like we were tortured by Enochian, Gavin, and the seagull anecdotes of random angels in this episode.  (Or like you'll be tortured as you liste…

In which we discuss the worst episode in the series: "Bloodlines." SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find all episodes organized by season on our Facebook page, or scroll throu…

[This episode includes references to sexual assault.] In which we discuss subconscious projection, the humanizing power of grief, and a tour de force performance from Kim Rhodes. SPOILERS for ALL s…

[This episode discusses suicidal ideation and self-harm.] In which Michelle finally notices jackets!  Discussion includes Hamlet (of course), Moby-Dick, Macbeth, Metatron's editing, and a dromedary …

In which we discuss the best part of being a nun (10 pm bedtime), the best units for soul storage, and the best deli in Northridge. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find all e…

In which we discuss Waiting For Aldo, Sam's inner middle school teacher, inside out Winchesters, and which of the Little Women Crowley is most like. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier epi…

In which we discuss creepypasta, the cesspool of the internet, the voyeurism of true crime, the perfect blend of shmoop and tragedy, and the secret of Michelle's rating system. SPOILERS for ALL seas…

In which we discuss vengeful ghosts, the horror of storage lockers, the appropriate size for headphones, and the fine line between restraint and underwriting. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for e…

In which Michelle gives Bethany yoga tips.  Discussion includes the sunshine of Donna, the many pronunciations of "Gadreel," the murkiness of "that," Dean's revisionist history, and Sam as Jane Eyre.…

[This episode includes discussion of suicide and sexual assault.  Time stamps for discussion of sexual assault: 41:35 - 44:32] In which we discuss the retconning of Genesis, the chemistry of hatred,…

In which we discuss everything coming up Crowley, the scope and risk-taking of season 9, and the life-changing magic of moving furniture. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find…

In which we discuss Dean's green light, the appropriate number of "dupes" per episode, and how to determine whether killing a major character is justified. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earl…

In which we discuss purity culture, stakes (both narrative and stabby), scissors ex machina, and why you should pay attention in 6th grade social studies. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earli…

In which we discuss Dickensian Orphan Dean, the Crimes of John Winchester (maybe not the ones this episode wants to ascribe to him!), the fallibility of memory, and the burden of doing "what's best f…

Though we are not under contract with the WGA or SAG-AFTRA, out of respect for their mutual strikes we are going on hiatus to stand in solidarity with the writers and actors whose work we so deeply a…