They've been married 19 years. She's intrigued by true crime. He couldn't care less. Can their marriage survive a podcast? Or will it end in murder?Meet the MacArthur's! Your soon-to-be favorite dysfunctional true crime couple. Offending your ear holes since 2022. Melissa brings the research and Daniel brings the sarcasm. Telling you cases of other dysfunctional couples whose love affair has ended in murder. With cases you might know and others you've certainly never heard before. You can find us on all podcast streaming services. With over 150 episodes to binge. We also have bonus episodes over at Patreon.com. For a small monetary fee, you get 4 spinoff shows each and every month. When it comes to happily ever after, just remember to: "Be careful, for marriage is a life sentence. And divorce is always the better option"... over Murder!
Without a confession or any physical evidence is the right person in prison? Or was this something other than murder?
Listen and find out.
Case begins at 15:30
Alright Michigan. It's your turn. We've got a Dogman, a giant squirrel, and some merman. What more could 11 listeners ask for? Alot really!
The Part 2 you've all been waiting for. We would love to hear your theories. You can send them to us at [email protected]
Let the laughter ensue! For this episode Meliss tells Daniel part 1 of the disappearance of Cora Crippen and her husband Dr. Harvey Crippen.
Case begins at 11:30
Alright Ohio! This one’s for you. We have a castle, an amusement park, and a famous prison. What more could you ask for? We love you Ohio!!!
As with all palate cleansers there is a ton of banter. If y…
You ready Ohio? Daniel sure wasn't. We have a Frogman, a Dogmen, and a Bessie. But the creme de la creme of Ohio Cryptids is the Melonheads. Want to learn where to find these fabulous creatures? Take…
This case takes place in the Netherlands.
9 years after a woman goes missing, her body is found in the most likely of places.
Case begins at 16:30
*listening back we sound super grumpy. We love California and all its charm. One day we will experience something we can’t explain and you all will be the first to know.
Tell us where to go to experie…
When a body washes ashore on Lake Coeur D'Alene in Northern Idaho, residents of the popular vacation destination have their suspicions as to who it must be. When the body's identity is confirmed, th…
Sometimes true crime can start to feel a little heavy. In honor of the upcoming SPOOKY season let's dive into the world of Cryptids. Listen as Melissa tells Daniel some cryptids from our home state o…
When a local political figure dies from a mysterious medical ailment, the affluent town of Dana Point California is left saddened and confused. But 6 months later, just before the case was to turn ic…
Warning- this case does include the death of a small child.
In August of 1996, the bodies of 2 people were found at the bottom of a cliff. Was this a tragic accident or had something more sinister hap…
Listen as Melissa wraps up this horrific case. Telling Daniel, the ends and outs of other relationships Katherine had in the past. Her interview with detectives and psychiatrists. What happened leadi…
2nd times the charm. Hopefully this works. Sorry about the delay.
Listen as Melissa tells Daniel a true crime case just hitting the airways.
Listen as Melissa tells Daniel another horrible case. You are welcome!
Case begins at 15:30
To Have and To Hold is a Till Death Do Us Part spin-off show only available on Patreon.com.
In these episodes Melissa shares cases of couples who kill... together. These cases seem to be much more cal…