Paint the Town Dead

After murdering two people, Rickey Ray Rector attempted to take his own life. He failed to do so and had instead essentially lobotomized himself. In this week's episode Andrew recounts the controvers…

Caitlin gives us a double feature! First, it's the story of Jessica Baggen, whose case went cold in the 90's, but made recent headlines. In part two, she discusses the still ongoing saga of a Jane Do…

Andrew and Caitlin's frustration with horrifying racism is back in a big way this week! We dive back back into the world of white supremacy and some of the worst that an already terrible group of peo…

It's a cult episode! Caitlin tells the story of Tony and Susan Alamo and the empire they created through false religion.

In the post-show, Andrew has more details on the Sonya Deville stalking case. T…

Updated number for anybody with information about Melissa "Missy" Witt: 1-800-440-1922

The crew hates school, though Caitlin has some modicum of excitement because she's going to finally graduate. And…

Caitlin covers the disappearance of Melissa "Missy" Witt. She was a college student with high hopes and was beloved by all.Unfortunately, her case remains unsolved, but the search for justice never e…

It's an Andrew week and we apologize. He tells us all the story of John Markle, the son of a movie star who seemed to have it all. Sadly, he would throw it all away in the most horrible way possible.

…

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/pr…

Andrew chronicles the many crimes John R. Kizer. He was a veterinarian and a pillar of his community, who used his knowledge of medicine to get away with murder for over a decade!

Caitlin has more inf…

In 1999, a young woman was thrown from a moving vehicle on the highway and killed. Investigators were left with very few leads before a major break in the case would come five years later.

Caitlin is…

Andrew brings yet another twisted tale from Randolph County. After a stormy night in Dalton, Arkansas, two members of the Elliott family had been found murdered, and the other two were missing. It wo…

Juli Busken was an Arkansas native, who dreamed of teaching dance to young children before her ambitions were taken from her. Caitlin recounts the story of Juli's disappearance in Oklahoma and the su…

Sending a venomous snake through the mail is not the worst decision that Bob Castleman would make in his life. The formerly respected attorney would manage to top that years later as part of a drug r…

Caitlin discusses the disappearance of Morgan Nick. Andrew was unavailable for recording this week, so Caitlin is joined by special guests Stephen and Oakley. After the story concludes, Caitlin has a…

Caitlin recounts the story of Billie Jean Phillips who was described as going through life like a "sexual Jet Ski," attracting the scorn of many. Unfortunately, Andrew's audio is less than great this…

Caitlin recounts the story of Dana Stidham, a young woman who went missing near Bella Vista, Arkansas. Andrew finally sees Spider-Verse and then quizzes Caitlin on wrestling stuff and she does real b…

The disappearance and search for Julie Heath, a young woman from Malvern, Arkansas with her whole life ahead of her.

Andrew finally watches Midsommar and Hereditary, and then he and Caitlin spoil the…

The shocking murder of Anne Pressly, a rising star in Arkansas television.

Later, Caitlin gets really mad at a Disney quiz.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.