Mystical Dispute

Special guest TheNerdySteve comes to the valiant defense of Alchemy, and debates with Garrett about the pros and cons of digital-only cards and mechanics in the new format Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's …

Special guest Ethan Saks (AKA LordTupperware) returns with yet another bone to pick about a format that had a... less than favorable reception, while Garrett defends the honor of what he considers a …

Carl and Garrett once again sum up a format by debating Alchemy-inspired changes and tweaks to a couple cards in Streets of New Capenna to improve on the (contentious!) format.

Short form limited Magi…

Carl and Garrett discuss the many rares of Streets of New Capenna and how to get the most out of building around them and playing them in games.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast …

Carl and Garrett welcome cameo special guest appearances from Chris Palmiotti (FloridaMun) and Benjy Jay (TaJoordan) to debate five different "bad" cards from Streets of New Capenna: sometimes underv…

Special guest and professional Magic competitor Sam Black details the differences in philosophy between Brewers and Tuners to Carl and Garrett and how and when to brew in Limited.

Check out Sam's Tw…

Carl and Garrett individually ranked all twelve tricks in Streets of New Capenna and debate the differences, as well as the pros, cons and where and when you should play them.

Short form limited Magic…

Carl and Garrett furiously debate the format all-star... Tavern Swindler? Listen to Garrett's entire Magic limited philosophy be put on trial as Carl picks apart boring vanilla filler creatures.

Short…

Carl and Garrett debate when you should NOT play the hands-down best color family in Streets of New Capenna, Brokers. Draft is self-correcting! Plus, the Preview Battle results are in!
…

Carl and Garrett have been enjoying (and crying at) the brand new format Streets of New Capenna and take a look at the color win rates as well as a weird card, the tax-paying 1/1 Sky Crier.

Short form…

Carl and Garrett polled the community for debate questions for the second ever quick-fire Grab Bag episode! Listen to them debate gripping topics from favorite worst Magic card to N64 vs. PS1. And ma…

Carl and Garrett participate in glorious combat to-the-death for preview predictions for the upcoming limited format Streets of New Capenna. Five commons, one champion, can Carl keep up his undefeate…

Carl and Garrett sum up Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty by debating Alchemy-inspired changes and tweaks to a couple cards to improve on the (pretty awesome!) format.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering deb…

Carl and Garrett debate a little-known edge case card called Basic Mountain in Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty. Jokes aside, red is a hotly debated topic in Kamigawa, with many players avoiding it but still o…

Special guest Greg Hatch defends Dragonfly Suit and a unique limited philosophy and approach. Garrett is still very skeptical on the poorly performing card as Carl plays moderator for the first time.
…

Carl and Garrett debate six different "bad" cards: cards that have a below average win rate. Sometimes you have to play situational cards, and sometimes situational cards are good... in the right sit…

Special guest Ethan Saks (AKA LordTupperware) has a bone to pick with the white uncommon saga The Fall of Lord Konda. Carl defends its honor and Garrett does an excellent job as impartial referee.

C…

Carl and Garrett debate the pros and cons of Imperial Oath, the top performing common in Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty, with a strange new guest who is picking... everything over it.

Short form limited Magic…

Carl and Garrett showdown over the top green (and overall!) uncommons in Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty. Carl defends the pure value of Blossom Prancer, while Garrett defends the destructive ninja turtle Kap…

Carl and Garrett pit top performing blue commons against each other: Carl defends the honor of the card selection engine saga The Modern Age, while Garrett defends the ninja-loving 1-drop Network Dis…