Believing the Bizarre: Paranormal Conspiracies & Myths
Believing the Bizarre is a paranormal podcast that dives into the unknown and the unusual every Tuesday.
From UFOs and hauntings to conspiracies and cryptids, we discuss a variety of paranormal topics and decide where they land on our Believability Scale - Believable, Viable, Skeptical, or Unbelievable.
We also accept and discuss listener-submitted paranormal encounters.
If you love creepy stories and horror content mixed with humor and a keen eye, we are the paranormal podcast for you.
Check out Believing the Bizarre - a podcast as bizarre as you are.
- Update frequency
- every 5 days
- Average duration
- 54 minutes
- Episodes
- 313
- Years Active
- 2020 - 2025
Terrified Together with Kaydra Brannan (Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast)
Our next Terrified Together is with friend of the podcast, Kaydra from Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast!
During this collab, we dive into two compelling listener submissions that took us from the Missis…
01:01:48 |
Tue 16 Sep 2025
The Black Eye Club
This week, we dive deep into one of the internet's most intriguing conspiracy theories: the Black Eye Club.
We explore the curious pattern of celebrities, politicians, and influential figures appea…
01:10:37 |
Tue 09 Sep 2025
The Smurl Family Haunting
The Smurl Family Haunting
This week, we dive deep into one of the most documented cases of demonic oppression in modern history - the Smurl haunting.
We explore how a working-class Catholic family…
00:52:44 |
Tue 02 Sep 2025
Terrified Together with Kassie (Tell Me Your Ghost Story Podcast)
Our next Terrified Together is with Kassie, the awesome host of the Tell Me Your Ghost Story Podcast.
Our first story comes from Mackie in Lubbock, Texas, who experienced a terrifying encounter that…
00:55:19 |
Tue 26 Aug 2025
The Creature that Wanted the Baby
Our first story comes from Baker in West Texas, who shares an incredible tale from 1985 about his newborn son's strange sleeping patterns and unexplained nocturnal visitors.
What started as puzzling…
00:53:01 |
Tue 19 Aug 2025
The North Canol Road Alien Abduction
The North Canol Road Alien Abduction
This week, we journey to the remote wilderness of Yukon, Canada, to explore the North Canal Road alien abduction case from 1987.
We follow Kevin, a seasoned ou…
01:00:37 |
Tue 12 Aug 2025
Haunted Schools: Part 1
This week, we dive into the dark hallways and shadowy corners of America's most haunted schools just as students head back to class.
We explore two particularly eerie Schools: Pocatello High School …
00:58:26 |
Tue 05 Aug 2025
The Haunted Pool Mannequin
The Haunted Pool Mannequin
This week, we dive into two chilling listener submissions that will make you think twice about your next swim or house purchase.
Get 60% off the Magic Mind offer with our…
01:21:15 |
Tue 29 Jul 2025
Ed Larson | Last Podcast on the Left - Interview
Ed Larson Interview - Last Podcast on the Left
*Note - this episode is raw and uncut, with no censorship. Listener discretion advised*
We are thrilled to present this interview with Ed Larson, come…
01:14:01 |
Fri 25 Jul 2025
Terrified Together with Drinking the Koolaid
We're thrilled to share our second official "Terrified Together," , where we welcomed Amanda and Cassidy from Drinking the Koolaid for some creepy listener submission stories.
Our first tale comes …
01:02:57 |
Tue 22 Jul 2025
Top 10 Mysterious Geoglyphs - Blind Ranking
This month's Blind Ranking is all about mysterious Geoglyphs! The way this game works is we have to rank each geoglyph by how mysterious it sounds - without knowing what comes next!
Patreon: Suppo…
00:30:57 |
Fri 18 Jul 2025
Mimics
Mimic Cryptids and Creatures
This week we discuss mimics - creatures that disguise themselves by imitating the voices and appearances of our loved ones. We explore the umbrella term of "mimic" and b…
01:05:17 |
Tue 15 Jul 2025
The Demonic Possession of David Glatzel and Arne Johnson
The Demonic Possession of David Glatzel and Arne Johnson
This week we dive into one of the most terrifying possession cases in American history - the haunting of the Glatzel family in 1980s Connecti…
00:58:08 |
Tue 08 Jul 2025
The Cursed Civil War Land
Our first tale comes from Ava in Newfoundland, Canada, who experienced something truly unsettling during a late-night phone call with friends in early 2022.
What started as typical teenage conversat…
01:09:32 |
Tue 01 Jul 2025
The Revenge of Resurrection Mary
The Revenge of Resurrection Mary
Our first story comes from a Sophia in Kentucky, who's been dealing with paranormal activity since childhood - from mysterious balls rolling out from under beds to…
00:57:49 |
Tue 24 Jun 2025
Top 10 Mysterious Discoveries - Blind Ranking
It's time for another Blind Rankings, and this month we are talking about mysterious discoveries!
In this segment, we have to place these mysterious discoveries from 1 through 10 without knowing wh…
00:29:50 |
Fri 20 Jun 2025
The Allagash Alien Abduction
The Allagash Alien Abductions
This week, we dive deep into one of the most compelling alien abduction cases of the 1970s - the Allagash incident.
Four college friends from the Massachusetts Colleg…
01:04:33 |
Tue 17 Jun 2025
Gnomes
In this episode of Believing the Bizarre, we dive deep into the mysterious world of gnomes - those diminutive creatures that might be hiding in plain sight as innocent lawn ornaments.
We explore th…
00:52:55 |
Tue 10 Jun 2025
Terrified Together with... Scared All the Time Podcast
In our inaugural episode of "Terrified Together," we partnered with Chris and Ed from "Scared All the Time Podcast" to dive into spine-chilling listener submissions that had us questioning reality it…
01:23:24 |
Tue 03 Jun 2025
The Tragic Demonic Investigation
In this chilling episode of Believing the Bizarre, we dive into two haunting tales that'll make you question what lurks in the shadows.
First, we explore Kay's family home in Pennsylvania, where for…
01:03:40 |
Wed 28 May 2025
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are the property of Tyler and Charlie. This content is not affiliated with or endorsed by eachpod.com.