Instead of discussing a single movie, the nerds decided to pick a random year and talk about a bunch of the movies that were released then — 12 in total, actually. The year they picked for this episode was 2004. Nope, no idea why.
Oh yeah, they tried to do this "game show"-style... but you know how they are. They couldn't stick properly to a format even if their life depended on it. But they did try, bless their hearts. They did try.