Shainin: The Problem-Solving Method You Haven't Heard Of

Author: Kevin Clay, Master Black Belt
Published: Tue 09 Sep 2025
Episode Link: https://why-they-fail-and-the-simple-key-to-success.castos.com/episodes/shainin-the-problem-solving-method-you-havent-heard-of

Shainin: The Problem-Solving Method You Haven't Heard Of

Welcome to the show notes for the "Why They Fail" podcast. In this episode, host Kevin Clay introduces a powerful and lesser-known precursor to Six Sigma. He sits down with Brian St. Pierre, an expert in Shainin Red X Problem Solving, to explore this unique methodology. You’ll learn how this approach has been a game-changer in various industries, tackling everything from exploding pipelines to nanometer-scale issues on semiconductor chips.

An Introduction to Shainin Red X Problem Solving

So, what exactly is the Shainin methodology? At its core, it's a structured approach for solving technical problems, especially those with hidden root causes. Brian explains that while there can be countless factors affecting a process, Shainin operates on the principle that one primary driver, the "Red X," is responsible for the most variation. By focusing on and eliminating this single dominant cause, you can achieve the biggest impact with the least amount of effort. This contrasts with other methods that may try to address multiple variables at once.

How Shainin Differs from Six Sigma

A key difference between Shainin and Six Sigma lies in their approach to problem-solving. Traditional methods often move from potential causes (the X's) to the problem (the Y). However, Shainin works backward. It starts with the defect—the Y—and uses clues to trace back to the Red X. This is accomplished through a technique called a "progressive search," which Brian demonstrates with a simple deck of cards analogy.

In addition, the statistical tools used in Shainin are designed to be practical and graphical, making them accessible to everyone, not just statisticians. This simplicity and the methodology's strict IP control have helped maintain its integrity over the years, preventing the "watering down" that has affected some Six Sigma certifications.

Shainin’s Historical Significance

The impact of this methodology extends beyond the factory floor. Dorian Shainin, the creator, played a crucial role in the Apollo space program by handling the reliability of the lunar module. His work ensured the module could withstand extreme stress, a factor that was critical in the safe return of the Apollo 13 astronauts.

Furthermore, Shainin's work with Motorola in the 1980s was a foundational element of what would become the Six Sigma revolution. The highest award given by the American Society for Quality is even named in his honor, a testament to his contributions.

Key Takeaways from this Podcast:

Shainin focuses on a single dominant cause, the "Red X," to solve complex technical problems.

The methodology works backward from the defect to uncover the root cause efficiently.

Its tools are graphical and practical, making complex statistics easy for anyone to understand.

‍ Dorian Shainin was responsible for the reliability of NASA's Apollo lunar module.

️ Strict IP control has maintained the integrity of the Shainin methodology and its certifications.

A Word from our Sponsor, Six Sigma Development Solutions.

This episode of "Why They Fail" is brought to you by Six Sigma Development Solutions, Inc., providing “Operational Excellence” Around the Globe!

Six Sigma Development Solutions, Inc. offers comprehensive Lean Six Sigma certification training, accredited by the International Association for Six Sigma Certification (IASSC) as an Authorized Training Organization. They have transformed over 100 organizations in 52 countries and achieved $100M USD in savings through Lean Six Sigma, certifying over 4000 practitioners. Their partners include Aerojet Rocketdyne, Dropbox, and Mercy Health, among others.

Key Certification Training we provide:

Lean Six Sigma Green Belt

Lean Six Sigma Black Belt

Lean Six Sigma Yellow Belt

LEAN Certification

We offer a variety of flexible training options to fit your needs! You can learn at your own pace with our Online Self-Paced, On-Demand courses, including our free Online Lean Six Sigma White Belt. We also offer comprehensive online programs for Lean Six Sigma Yellow Belt, Green Belt, and Black Belt certifications. If you prefer in-person instruction, we can come onsite to your organization or you can join our public training sessions, available live virtually or in person at any of our 52 training centers. Every one of our courses can be delivered either live virtually or live in person, ensuring you get the learning experience that works best for you.

Answering the Question "What is ...":