1. EachPod

uswithoutThem - Podcast

uswithoutThem

The uswithoutThem Podcast explores the musical output of one of the greatest bands of the 21st century: mewithoutYou. Hosts Nic Houle, Steven Eiler, and Joel Harrison each bring their love of mewithoutYou and some specific expertise to their song-by-song analysis of the mewithoutYou discography. Steven, a music theory educator and expert, breaks down the musical themes of each track and draws connections between songs and albums. Joel, a Ph.D. in religion with expertise in philosophy of religion and Christianity, explains the lyrical themes and the connections to and critiques of evangelical Christianity. Nic, a devoted mewithoutYou listener and Tolkein reader, ties these threads together with the perspective of the average mwY fan listening to the podcast.

Music Music Commentary
Update frequency
every 10 days
Average duration
97 minutes
Episodes
53
Years Active
2022 - 2025
Share to:
Staff Picks 08/15/2025 (Teaser)

Staff Picks 08/15/2025 (Teaser)

In this Staff Picks bonus episode, Steven joins the crew as they each spotlight hidden gems and recent favorites. Nic dives into Birds in Row, Steven discusses the Bluey soundtrack and takes a nostal…

00:03:42  |   Fri 15 Aug 2025
Staff Picks 07/17/25

Staff Picks 07/17/25

It’s the inaugural episode of our bonus series Staff Picks! In this series, the guys spotlight newer or under-the-radar albums they think deserve some love. Joel kicks things off with The Quiet Year

00:21:26  |   Thu 17 Jul 2025
Interview: Mike Almquist

Interview: Mike Almquist

It's our first bonus episode! The guys sit down with Mike Almquist, manager extraordinaire, to talk all things spider songs, touring nightmares, early 2000s emo, and a lot more!

Patreon subscribers g…

01:56:49  |   Fri 04 Jul 2025
S3|E18: Brother, Sister Finale with Aaron Weiss

S3|E18: Brother, Sister Finale with Aaron Weiss

We've reached the finale! The guys are joined by Aaron Weiss to discuss the album, recollections from the recording process, and some highlights from the season, and discover together that sometimes.…

01:32:21  |   Wed 11 Jun 2025
S3|E17: In A Sweater Poorly Knit, Pt. 2

S3|E17: In A Sweater Poorly Knit, Pt. 2

Surprise! Part 2 of our "In A Sweater Poorly Knit" discussion is here. We talk holy fools and fields without fences, correct a mistake three years in the making regarding circles, probe the limits an…

02:10:52  |   Fri 30 May 2025
S3|E16: In A Sweater Poorly Knit, Pt. 1

S3|E16: In A Sweater Poorly Knit, Pt. 1

We have arrived. But do we still exist? The guys get into the final track of Brother, Sister, including the haunting melodies, the story of little Moses drifting down the Nile, and unpacking the reas…

02:03:36  |   Wed 28 May 2025
S3|E15: Brownish Spider

S3|E15: Brownish Spider

The guys are one track away from the end of the record. What is it they think they've learned? Nic, Joel, and Steven get into reflections of reality, the mechanics of a harp, more mystical experience…

01:56:14  |   Sat 05 Apr 2025
S3|E14: O, Porcupine, Pt. 2

S3|E14: O, Porcupine, Pt. 2

The boys are back with the rest of O, Pocupine, including breaking down the guest spot from the inimitable Jeremy Enigk. 

Want more uswithoutThem? Consider supporting us on Patreon!

We're offering …

02:05:27  |   Mon 10 Feb 2025
S3|E13: O, Porcupine, Pt. 1

S3|E13: O, Porcupine, Pt. 1

Nic, Steven, and Joel discuss locust swarms and whether or not they could resemble the iconic "fish tower," cross-overs with "Torches Together" and "Bullet to Binary," a LOT of biblical references (P…

01:43:07  |   Sun 15 Dec 2024
S3|E12: In A Market Dimly Lit

S3|E12: In A Market Dimly Lit

The guys get into the groove of the mechanics of vinyl records, come up with yet another t-shirt idea, discuss the implications of Samson and a donkey's jawbone, Say Anything (the movie), Say Anythin…

02:27:00  |   Sun 01 Dec 2024
S3|E11: C-Minor

S3|E11: C-Minor

Our rodent friend is back! The guys talk about the meaning of the mice, an appearance by Aaron's father, another Donne connection, and that old voice of loneliness and fear. Devil disappear! This is …

02:10:48  |   Sun 27 Oct 2024
S3|E10: Orange Spider

S3|E10: Orange Spider

Steven, Nic, and Joel discuss "Orange Spider," the second of the Spider Songs on Brother, Sister. Who are the mice, why are "we" trying to kill them, and what is Aaron laughing at? We get into it!

 

01:11:35  |   Wed 09 Oct 2024
S3|E9: The Sun And The Moon

S3|E9: The Sun And The Moon

We've reached the [mystical?] center of the album! Nic, Joel, and Steven talk about the simplicity and complexity of faith, the possible sources of inspiration for the image of the sun and the moon, …

02:36:46  |   Sat 21 Sep 2024
S3|E8: Nice And Blue (Pt. 2)

S3|E8: Nice And Blue (Pt. 2)

The one where Joel says he's not sure what they're going to talk about and then the guys proceed to spin off a dozen different theories about the track!

Want more uswithoutThem? Consider supporting…

02:23:33  |   Thu 05 Sep 2024
S3|E7: A Glass Can Only Spill What It Contains

S3|E7: A Glass Can Only Spill What It Contains

We get into allllll the animal metaphors, references to Buddhism and mysticism, and music theory you could ever want. We all agree this is an underrated track in the mewithoutYou catalog, and this ep…

02:14:15  |   Sat 24 Aug 2024
S3|E6: Yellow Spider

S3|E6: Yellow Spider

Not since the instrumental tracks on [A-->B] Life have we spent so much time talking about so little! The Spider Songs are deceptively simple, and the guys try to unpack every little aspect of this f…

01:35:37  |   Wed 07 Aug 2024
S3|E5: Wolf Am I! (And Shadow)

S3|E5: Wolf Am I! (And Shadow)

Here we go, showin' off again, self-impressed by how well we can start a line of thinking and then jump from thought to thought, interrupting and starting again (music, philosophy, the Bible, music a…

02:13:49  |   Wed 31 Jul 2024
S3|E4: The Dryness and the Rain

S3|E4: The Dryness and the Rain

Tornados, parables, medieval music notation, Islam--this episode has it all! Come along with us as we dive into Brother, Sister's second track, "The Dryness and the Rain."

Want more uswithoutThem? C…

02:09:28  |   Wed 24 Jul 2024
S3|E3: Messes of Men, Pt. 2

S3|E3: Messes of Men, Pt. 2

In part 2 of our Messes of Men discussion, we finally get past the first verse and into the rest of the track! The guys discuss the philosophy of history, more on mystical experience, what a singular…

02:22:19  |   Wed 17 Jul 2024
S3|E2: Messes of Men, Pt. 1

S3|E2: Messes of Men, Pt. 1

Let's. Get. INTO IT. Steven, Joel, and Nic dive headfirst into the opening track of Brother, Sister, "Messes of Men," discussing how different this opening track is from the everything that came befo…

01:34:01  |   Wed 10 Jul 2024
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are the property of uswithoutthempod. This content is not affiliated with or endorsed by eachpod.com.