This true crime podcast episode recounts the murder of 18-year-old Jaci Graham, a high school cheerleader. The investigation reveals a complex web of relationships, including Jaci's secret and illegal affair with her 44-year-old coach, Nate Slater, and the subsequent involvement of Jaci's parents. Jaci's mother, Liz, driven by jealousy and a secret affair with Slater herself, ultimately committed the murder. Jaci's father, Walt, was also implicated, running an illegal identity theft operation and drug trafficking scheme at the homeless shelter he managed. The case highlights the devastating consequences of hidden secrets and toxic relationships.