A true crime podcast recounts the murder of Dylan Vincent, a man who discovered his new wife, Brooke, was transgender hours after their wedding. The shocking revelation led to a violent confrontation, resulting in Dylan's brutal death in a church bathroom. The investigation uncovers a complex web of secrets, including Brooke's gambling addiction, her mother's involvement in concealing Brooke's identity, and an affair between Dylan and Brooke's adopted sister. Ultimately, Brooke is convicted of second-degree murder, her defense claiming self-defense in the face of abuse.