In this gripping true crime case from Carbondale, Illinois, 19-year-old college student Ashlee Whitmore is found strangled in her grandmother’s home in May 2014, setting off a shocking murder investigation that unravels family secrets, forbidden affairs, and deadly jealousy. This real-life murder mystery dives deep into the lives of suspects including a retired farmer with a dark past, an angry ex-boyfriend, and a devout aunt hiding a deadly secret.