A respected university professor is found brutally murdered in his office, a luxury fountain pen driven into his throat. As police investigate, they uncover a tangled web of academic rivalries, student scandals, and a young woman's desperate fight for justice. Was Emily Bronley-McGuyver a victim pushed too far, or a cold-blooded killer? This gripping true crime case from June 2015 shocked the University of Wisconsin-Madison, leading to a high-profile murder trial filled with shocking twists, internet search evidence, and a final verdict that still sparks debate.