Season 2, Episode 17 | George Washington: Merit, Power, and the Birth of Civilian Leadership

Did you know that George Washington could have become an American Caesar, but instead chose to walk away from power? Unlike Napoleon or Cromwell, he rejected dictatorship and dynasty, setting the precedent for civilian control of the military, limited executive authority, and the peaceful transfer of power.

In this episode of This Constitution, host Matthew Brogdon sits down with eminent historian Jeremy Black to trace Washington’s extraordinary balancing act. From the battlefields of the Revolution to the presidency, Washington navigated fragile institutions, fractious states, and the lure of personal power and, in doing so, set precedents that continue to define American politics.

The conversation explores Washington’s role as a “meritocratic monarch,” how he differed from figures like George III, Napoleon, and Oliver Cromwell, and why his restraint proved essential to building a constitutional republic. They discuss the challenges of commanding a multi-state army, the dangers of potential coups, his deliberate retirement, and the legacy of leadership “for country, not party.”

They also tackle a deeper question: what does Washington’s example teach us about the relationship between military power and constitutional government? His decision to submit force to law, ambition to restraint, and leadership to the service of the people remains one of the defining features of American constitutionalism.

In This Episode

• (00:03) Opening and introduction
• (00:56) Washington as a "meritocratic monarch"
• (02:34) Contrasts with George III and Napoleon
• (04:09) Washington’s challenges with Congress and state governments
• (05:31) Comparison to the French Revolution and use of force
• (07:01) Civilian control of the military: Historical continuity
• (08:20) Presidential power and restraint
• (09:37) Washington’s post-war precedent
• (10:54) Use of force in domestic rebellions
• (12:23) Continuity from military to executive leadership
• (13:04) Constitutional practices in the Continental Army
• (14:48) Managing rivalries and federalism in the army
• (16:12) Geographic shifts in the Revolutionary War
• (17:25) Washington’s political skills and resource allocation
• (19:41) National identity and the crucible of war
• (22:29) Army vs. Navy in American political culture
• (23:48) Washington’s non-autocratic leadership
• (24:32) Washington as American Cincinnatus
• (25:56) Washington’s farewell address and peaceful transfer of power
• (27:44) Conclusion and legacy
• (28:08) Podcast outro and next episode teaser

Notable Quotes

• (01:00) "I see George Washington as a formative figure in America and an example of the best type of what I call a meritocratic monarch." — Jeremy Black
  
  
• (04:13) "Washington does this with enormous skill, not in easy circumstances." — Jeremy Black
  
  
• (08:21) "One of the patterns that derives directly from Washington is that of the subordination of the military to civil authority." — Jeremy Black
  
  
• (08:37) "Washington was not an American Caesar. He did not create himself as a dictator either." — Jeremy Black
  
  
• (19:44) "America is born in the crucible of war, because that defines the boundaries of America." — Jeremy Black
  
  
• (23:06) "The expression of liberty becomes that of serving on land in military forces." — Jeremy Black
  
  
• (27:35) "I think one could say his politics were for the people, for his country, rather than for himself or his party." — Jeremy Black