How Erika Took BARSTOOL From A Blog To $550 MILLION Empire w/ Dave Portnoy, Big Cat, Call Her Daddy | The Sagnik Show

Erika Ayers Badan joined Barstool Sports as CEO in 2016 when the company was generating about $3 million in revenue, and she stepped down in 2024, with the company's revenue reportedly reaching around $250 million by the time she left.

Show notes:

0:00 Intro

1:27 Alex Cooper leaving Barstool Sports

4:41 Brand vs Personality

7:13 The growth of Call Her Daddy

8:33 Pat McAfee leaving Barstool Sports

9:00 Erika joins Barstool Sports

11:32 The underdogs who won

14:06 Leaving corporate for Barstool

17:11 Handling controversies - Mintzy

20:31 Vice News is bankrupt 

21:48 Barstool's business

24:47 Was Barstool Gold a failure?

28:09 The Quiet Quitting Debate

31:39 Dave Portnoy's hustle

32:39 I am a fan of Erika

34:24 Barstool Sport's sold back for $1

35:48 Why Barstool didn't fit PENN

37:42 Erika has a new job!

Welcome to The Sagnik Show — where politics, media, and identity collide.

Over the past decade, I’ve worked across legacy and new media, from FOX to independent platforms alongside people like Tucker Carlson, Saagar Enjeti, and Krystal Ball.

I didn’t come to the U.S. to cover politics—I just happened to fall into it. What followed was an unexpected crash course in the American political machine, taught by some of the sharpest (and most polarizing) voices in the business.

This show is my attempt to process what I’ve learned—and unlearned.

I also speak with creators and entrepreneurs building media on their own terms—people forging new paths outside the traditional gatekeepers.

I’m not here to sell you anything. None of this is monetized. I’m just grateful you’re listening.

IG: @sssagnic

YT: @thesagnikbasu

X: @_sagnikbasu