'Bachelor in Paradise' Episode 9 Recap, Plus Allyshia Claims Kat Had a Boyfriend While Filming

Paradise After Dark is the unofficial late-night aftershow of Bachelor in Paradise 2025, and in tonight's recap, Stefanie and Jackie are discussing the highs and lows of episode 9. But first, they dive into Allyshia's story about Kat Izzo on The Viall Files. Did she actually have a boyfriend while filming the show?

Episode 9 recap:

• Hannah Brown finally being included in intros
• The challenges: The camping challenge (the bugs!) and the "dagger" challenge (what was the point of this one?). Also, was the therapist tipped off by the producers?
• Keith wanting to leave after the camping challenge
• Alexe and Andrew taking the next step in their relationship
• The new alliances forming: Kat/Dale and Jess/Spencer vs. Alexe/Andrew and Bailey/Jeremy
• The tie breaker vote — and who goes home this episode

Watch Paradise After Dark on YouTube here: https://www.youtube.com/@shesallbach

Thanks to our sponsors:

Lumi Gummies are available nationwide. Go to http://www.LumiGummies.com and use code SHESALLBACH for 30% off your order.

Earn points on rent and around your neighborhood — wherever you call home — by going to http://www.JoinBilt.com/SHESALLBACH.