The affirmative team provides a defense of the topic wording that can include parts or its entirety. They will offer an initial “case” in their opening presentation, rebuild it in their response by refuting the negative attacks and offer key final comparisons in their rebuttals.
The negative team’s job is to disprove the affirmative thesis. Their initial presentation should poke holes in the initial affirmative presentation and outline any of their own proofs for their side. The negative response will point out the key points unanswered by the affirmative response and refute attacks on their proofs. Their rebuttal will offer key final comparisons.
William Baker (Moderator) New York University, Director, Global Debate Fund
Richard Heinzl WorldCare International, Inc., Global Medical Director
Richard Migliori UnitedHealth Group, Executive Vice President, Medical Affairs and Chief Medical Officer
David Gruber Alvarez & Marsal Healthcare Industry Group (HIG), Managing Director and Director of Research
Michael K. Gusmano The Hastings, Center Research Scholar