Mystical Dispute

Carl is not done, he is angry, chomping at the bit, and desperate to prove that forty-two cards (or more?!) is the right thing to do. In limited. Where you are allowed to play just forty. So Garrett…

Carl and Garrett debate the most complicated, complex, intricate cards in the set: mostly vanilla creatures. Yes, Garrett is defending them. Why do you ask?

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering deb…

Carl and Garrett debate a universal exile anything removal spell at instant speed vs. a sorcery speed shock. I bet you wonder who writes these episode summaries huh?

Short form limited Magic: The Gath…

Carl and Garrett come back to a classic: combat trick vs. a removal spell. Also, this format is awesome.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gard…

Carl and Garrett are back in action, this time debating a single blue common vs. TWO copies of a different blue common. How have ya'll been after all this time?!

Short form limited Magic: The Gatherin…

Carl and Garrett share some news, explain their recent absence, and debate what is more important - living life, or playing this card game (it's close).

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate …

Carl and Garrett return from a short hiatus to debate the glass cannon higher risk synergy card and the pure value removal creature card. Guess who's on which side.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathe…

Carl and Garrett debate over how well a, you guess it, 1 mana 1/1 will fare as we decend into the brand new format, The Lost Caverns of Ixalan!

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast c…

Carl and Garrett debate a color fixing tapped value land in this adventure-filled format.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate…

Carl and Garrett do a for-real old school official debate, taking opposite sides to duke it out over the surprising news that Play Boosters will soon be replacing both Draft Boosters and Set Boosters…

Carl and Garrett debate the best performing blue common, which is a conditional counterspell, so you can kinda see where this one is going.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-ho…

Special guest Robert Conroy (AKA viralmisnomer) joins to answer some questions from Garrett and the MD community about 17Lands and share some exciting new features.

Check out Robert on Twitter at @1…

Carl and Garrett meet IN PERSON for the first time EVER and recap their awesome weekend at MagicCon Vegas 2023 for their 100th episode. This episode was recorded LIVE and UNEDITED and also in VIDEO, …

Carl and Garrett set forth on the best adventures of all: data, numbers and charts provided by 17Lands for the new Wilds of Eldraine format.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-h…

Carl and Garrett found one of the most contentious preview cards in recent memory so, of course, they battle each other to the ends of the earth.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast…

Carl and Garrett suggest some buffs to rebalance LTR limited, and maybe make White and Green suck just a little bit less.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase…

Carl and Garrett debate the below-average-game-in-hand-win-rate cards of Lord of the Rings and when they are (and are not) playing them.

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hoste…

Carl and Garrett debate one of the best uncommons in the best performing color against one of the best commons in the second best performing color.

Check out Carl's article about forcing Blue Red on…

Carl and Garrett debate which of two extremely powerful uncommons in two extremely powerful colors is more extremely powerful than the other extremely powerful one. And they also pronounce everything…

Carl and Garrett debate which basic land cycler is best within its color, skillfully dodging any conversation about color power imbalance in the Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth.

Check out S…