The Sinking of the Essex Part 3: Heartbreaks & Bellyaches

Send us a text

The final chapter of the Essex tragedy unfolds as a haunting testament to human survival instinct pushed beyond moral boundaries. After spotting land, the starved crew members experience a fleeting moment of hope—only to discover Henderson Island offers little salvation. Despite its lush appearance, fresh water remains scarce, forcing these desperate men to make an impossible choice: continue the journey or remain stranded.

When tragedy forces them back to sea, nature's cruelty intensifies. Separated by a violent storm, the three whale boats drift apart, each crew now isolated in their private nightmare. As rations disappear completely, these ordinary sailors confront the unthinkable—consuming the flesh of their dead companions. First, they use those who die naturally, but eventually, on Captain Pollard's boat, they resort to drawing lots to determine who would be sacrificed so others might survive.

The racial dynamics add another disturbing dimension, as all four Black sailors perish and are consumed before most white crew members. After 89 days adrift, rescue finally comes—first for Owen Chase's boat, then for Captain Pollard and his lone remaining companion, found sucking marrow from human bones. Meanwhile, the three men who chose to remain on Henderson Island survive against all odds until their eventual rescue.

What happens after survival proves equally compelling. Captain Pollard, once a respected commander, ends his days as a night watchman after losing a second ship. Owen Chase writes a successful account of the disaster and returns to a prosperous whaling career. Some find meaning through religion, others through continuing their maritime lives. But all carry the weight of what they did to survive, their stories serving as a chilling reminder of what happens when civilization's veneer cracks under the pressure of pure survival.

What moral compromises would you make to stay alive? Follow History's A Disaster for more stories that challenge our understanding of human nature under extreme conditions.

Facebook: historyisadisaster
Instagram: historysadisaster
email: [email protected]

Special thank you to Lunarfall Audio for producing and doing all the heavy lifting on audio editing since April 13, 2025, the Murder of Christopher Meyer episode https://lunarfallaudio.com/