10 Fantasy Books Critics Loved But Fans Hated

Some fantasy novels win awards, earn glowing reviews, and get called “masterpieces” by critics… but when actual fans picked them up? They cried, “Boring!” “Pretentious!” and “I want my weekend back!”

In this episode of Fantasy for the Ages, Jim counts down 10 fantasy novels since 1930 that critics adored but general readers couldn’t stand. From sprawling gothic castles to postmodern fever dreams, these are the books that divided the book world like no others.

📚 Expect witty commentary, fiery reader quotes, and a reminder that not every “classic” is a fan favorite.

✨ Support the channel and get access to perks by joining our Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/FantasyForTheAges

👍 Don’t forget to Like, Subscribe, and hit the Bell so you never miss an episode!

Let’s chat!

💬 Which of these “critically acclaimed” fantasy books did you actually enjoy? And which ones drove you up the wall? Comment below — we’d love to hear your thoughts.

#FantasyBooks #WorstFantasyNovels #BookTube #FantasyForTheAges

Want to purchase books/media mentioned in this episode?

The Buried Giant: https://t.ly/rZYpE

Dictionary of the Khazars: https://t.ly/o18tg

Giles Goat-Boy: https://t.ly/o7uUH

Lanark: https://t.ly/MZdJR

Lincoln in the Bardo: https://t.ly/3xpm-

Little, Big: https://t.ly/nmFh4

Titus Groan: https://t.ly/Cux7C

Vellum: https://t.ly/welYg

The Vorrh: https://t.ly/S099c

Winter’s Tale: https://t.ly/f1kZq

Ways to connect with us:

Follow Jim/Father on Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/13848336-jim-scriven

Join us on Discord: https://discord.gg/jMWyVJ6qKk

Follow us on "X": @Fantasy4theAges

Follow us on Blue Sky: @fantasy4theages.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram: fantasy_for_the_ages

Follow us on Mastodon: @[email protected]

Email us: [email protected]

Check out our merch: https://www.newcreationsbyjen.com/collections/fantasyfortheages

Jim’s Microphone: Blue Yeti https://tinyurl.com/3shpvhb4

————————————————————————————

Music and video elements licensed under Envato Elements:

https://elements.envato.com/