Deadly Wrong Way: The Judy Kirby Tragedy

A white Pontiac Firebird speeds northbound in the southbound lanes of State Road 67 at nearly 100 mph, T-tops removed, blonde hair blowing in the wind. Inside, four children clutch whatever they can as witnesses report them screaming. The driver, 32-year-old Judy Kirby, appears eerily calm, "stoic" and "on a mission" according to those who swerved to avoid her.

What drives a mother of ten to commit an act that would claim seven lives, including three of her own children, her nephew celebrating his 10th birthday, and a father with his two teenagers in an oncoming van? Was it the postpartum depression diagnosed just months after giving birth to her youngest child? The paranoia that federal agents were watching her? Or was it something more deliberate – a calculated decision that would lead to one of the longest prison sentences in Indiana history?

We explore the devastating crash that shook Martinsville, Indiana on March 25, 2000, examining the evidence that led prosecutors to charge Judy with seven counts of murder rather than manslaughter. The haunting timeline reveals a woman who drove at lethal speeds for nearly two miles in the wrong direction, passing multiple opportunities to correct course, moments after calmly purchasing candy bars at a gas station for the children who would perish minutes later.

Beyond the courtroom drama and 215-year sentence that followed, we delve into the lasting trauma experienced by survivors, including Louise Reel Casari who lost her husband and two children in the crash. "For the survivor, it is never really over," she reflects. "You just tuck it away and continue with life." Two decades later, seven crosses still stand at the crash site – silent sentinels marking lives cut tragically short and forcing us to confront difficult questions about mental health, accountability, and justice when unthinkable tragedy strikes.

Join our Patreon community at patreon.com/69south for early episode releases, exclusive bonus content, and access to legal documents that deepen your understanding of this complex case.

Do you want to advertise with 69 SOUTH?

Visit Rosie's Posy for all your farmstead, sourdough and flower needs at 6082 E. Hadley Rd. , Moorseville, Indiana. 

Ad for 69 South Tees

Scented Jewels
We’ve got the coolest wax melts ever. Dive into a world of many aromas at shopscentedjewels.com

Support the show

Disclaimer: All defendants are INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY in a court of law. All facts are alleged until a conviction!